Two things that jump out at me - winter home, not lived in during the summer; if this is the case, I'm also going to assume you'll be turning off the AC and HVAC when you are not at the home, which will lead to increased RH and possible greenhouse effect, none of which is good for wood or laminate products. It sounds like you'll have the best results with a vinyl installation - though keep all the blinds drawn etc, since vinyl is resistant to moisture, but not temperature, and too much direct sunlight with no AC/circulation can lead to peeling/lifting corners. Vinyl will also install better over the pre-existing tiles, which leads me to...
Two - installing over anything other than concrete or plywood/OSB or similar is typically not warranted by the manufacturer and as such, if you do choose to install over those tiles, you'll be voiding your warranty and I would not recommend doing this for future insurance or resale purposes. Countless times I've been asked this question and my answer is always the same - do it right, the right way, right now. You can't go back in time and once it's laid, you've assumed all responsibility, especially if you've done the install yourself. When it comes to installing over existing tiles, its always done in an attempt to save money, there is NO other good reason for it. Don't cheap out and save a couple hundred now only to end up with a failed install and having to spend thousands out of pocket to get it fixed or replaced later. Especially since you've already indicated that the house will be sitting vacant for long periods of time, which opens up the possibility for all kinds of things to go wrong. Get the tiles removed, prep the subfloor (you may have to replace some of those panels), and install according to all the directions recommended by the dealer and manufacturer.
|