Okay, let me give you a little more information on my floors. My subfloor is 3/4" diagonal solid wood planks on 2"x10" joists spaced 16" O.C. I will be putting down 1/2" plywood underlayment before laying out 15# roofing felt and installing the 5/8" horizontal solid bamboo. Installing approximately 850 sq ft, so I don't think I want to do much manual nailing.
I'm as far from an expert on the subject as possible, but from what I've read, people seem to be specific that the subfloor is secured to the joists, but the underlayment is only secured to the subfloor and
not the joists. For example, the Engineered Wood Association (APA) put out a very detailed paper on plywood underlayment installation and specifically recommends that for ideal holding power, the fastener should not exceed the width of the underlayment and subfloor. You can get the paper
here. I do plan on screwing down the subfloor planks to the joists using deck screws prior to installation of the underlayment.
In my case, the 2" ring shank nail would extend 3/4" below the subfloor, which doesn't sound like a good idea. Additionally, I'm worried that a 16 gauge 2" ring shank nail will split the tongues when I do the blind nailing on the first few rows of flooring.
Another option that I'm leaning towards is to use 18 gauge 1/4" crown x 1-1/4" flooring staples for both the underlayment attach and the first/last flooring planks (still plan to use my 16 gauge side stapler for the rest of the flooring). These are the same staples used for 1/2" flooring and stapling plywood underlayment seems to be very common, though I've seen some say that 18 gauge staples won't do it.
I realize this is getting into the finer points of proper flooring installation and after seeing how poorly my 60 year floor was attached, I'm sure anything I do will work fine. But since I'm going to all the trouble to tear up and reinstall new floors, I may as well do it right.